Hero at the Fall

Hero at the Fall is the final installment of the A Rebel of the Sands novels and, boy, was it great.

After finally escaping the Sultan's harem while spying for the Rebel Prince, she finds herself trapped behind a magic wall inside the city with only half of rebellions leaders. The others have been captured and somehow taken out of the city to an unknown location. Amani, being a Djinni's daughter and also somehow injured, she's had trouble grasping onto sands she once controlled. After kidnapping the princess that betrayed them and finding how to get out, they start a long trip to find their Rebel Prince. They end up encountering more Djinni, Shadowalkers, invading armies, and old family, not to mention the golden killing machines that can vaporize people who are being commanded by the Sultan and power by her Djinni father and that's before they even get to Prince Ahmed and the others. She is steps up, feeling very much inadequate to lead the rebellion against the Sultan that always seems three steps ahead and always moving forward.

My favorite thing of this whole series is the voice. Even after a year waiting for this book to come out, I instantly felt at home back on the sands with Amani and Jin. There are some books that it takes a while to get back into the groove of a story. Not here. Alwyn Hamilton's voice that she presents is distinct and memorable  making it easy to step back into Amani's shoes and pick up right where we left off.

What makes this book great too is every moment there is something going on. We don't have a fall interest though the action tempers when people talk and discuss. We see the internal debate that is fighting insider her: the feeling of inadequacy because she's just seventeen and getting people killed, not intentionally of course, as wells as the "gifts" the Sin Maker that would help people live. Then, of course, there are the amazing moments when she sails over the Sea of Sands or faces the Destroyer of the World, and that is even before she reaches the Sultan. There is constantly something happening that kept me engaged and wanting more.

The books is mainly about Amani and there isn't much conversation between her and Jin or her and Shazad. There isn't much dialog in general comparatively to internal thought and storytelling. But that is okay here. It is set up as a storyteller would have told it and it fits well here.

The relationship between her and Jin is rocky here because of the stress Amani is under and does rely heavily on the previous stories. So if the reader comes to this book first, they would probably be disappointed in the building of this relationship because in Hero at the Fall is isn't really there. It is told of, but not given the opportunity to be shown here and, again, I'm okay with it.  There reaches a point toward the end when Jin and Amani become intimate. The moment is descriptive of her feelings more than physical touches. It was modestly done while still getting the point across. So, if that makes you uncomfortable, you can easily skim through and read the dialog or skip to the next chapter. If it doesn't bother you so much, I think it was done well.

I also have nothing bad to say about the characters. They didn't change/flip flop on themselves or do something uncharacteristically them. They grew as people do. They had their virtues and vices. We were given the internal dialog for Amani and her struggles that change throughout the book. I enjoyed getting to know them.

It was great fun and I'd like to read them again. The books before are A Rebel of the Sand and Traitor to the Throne.

Traitor to the Throne

Traitor to the Throne is the sequel to Rebel of the Sands. I would recommend when you read this, make sure you read the first book right before you read this one. There are lots of little things that correlate between the two books that I had a hard time remembering, because I read the first one last year. 

This is about Amani and the Rebellion that wants to dethrone the Sultan. They are in full blown rebellion mode when their camp gets ambushed and they are forced to flee. A few of the rebels follow her out. While there, and after a fight with Jin, she gets knocked out and finds herself waking up in the Sultan's Palace as his prisoner. But he doesn't want to simply lock up this Demji (forgive my spelling if it's wrong) whose power he can use, but he wants to show her off. Placing her in his harem, not to be touched by anyone. 

Surrounding her are "ghosts of her past," almost literally, and betrayal is around every corner. She doesn't know who she can trust and ends up being somewhat sympathetic to the Sultan, the man whom the Rebellion is trying to over throw. I know I was sympathetic to him at points in the story. 

If you can stand the info dump in a few places, especially toward the beginning, you will enjoy the book. 

The main characters are very strong individuals. They have strong presences and make them believable people. Not everyone is solely bad or completely good. I do wish the side characters were more fleshed out. They blended together and sometimes it was hard to tell them apart. This hindered parts of the story especially when certain ones die. One of Amani's "ghosts" dies and I cried for this character. I felt her/him. But when other of the rebellion die, named and named, I have much harder time feeling for them. I hope in the next book, we get more background for these characters, especially if they are going to die on us. 

The world building is amazing. Hamilton spent a lot of time developing the stories and backgrounds of different people and mythologies. But she tends to info dump to get a point across. That can be jarring and send you out of the book. 

Some of the betrayals I didn't see coming, others I did. The plot was very well thought out, even for a second book in a trilogy. It felt like a sequel, but it held its own for the most part. 

I was really put off by the abrupt ending of this book though. It is in set up for the third book, but I was initially thinking that it was only a two book series. I was mistaken and disappointed in a way. I was prepared for it to end, but it left me hanging. 

The next one is Hero at the Fall.

Rebel of the Sands

Rebel of the Sands is  one that I would recommend and is part of the Rebel of the Sands Series. It is one that got me out of a funk of not wanting
to read. It was a book I finished in four days, which can be quite a feat some weeks.

I ended up describing this book to my husband as a mixture between the Wild West and Aladdin. It takes place in a fantasy world that is supposed to resemble Saudi Arabia or an equivalent (which was nice considering most of fantasy novels take place in northern Europe/Britain). But it's not only a time of scimitars and horses, though there are a few of them, there are also guns and magical beings.

One of the things that I really enjoyed about Rebel of the Sands was the religions and mythology in the story. It plays a vital role in the story as the plot moves forward and I think Alwyn Hamilton does a good job in presenting it to the reader. I also think she's gutzy because I've read a bunch of books who keep away from religion because they think it would be a turnoff for many readers. But Alwyn Hamilton didn't and made it vital the story. I thank her for it.

I also enjoyed the mythical creatures that come to life out of the sands. There are moments when Amani, the main character, recalls moments in the past to better understand these creatures that attack in the night. It gives us Amani's background, her spunky personality, and the world in which we are being brought to. There were many different types of creatures that roam the dark here. From Nightmares that kill you in your sleep, to Demdji--half human half Djinni--who are often killed for being an abomination, to the majestic Buraqi--immortal horses--that are faster than anything but a train. The world building was very well done in this book.

Amani and Jin were interesting characters. They were well developed. They ended up fighting, of course, and their fight and make up was believable.

The only thing I that I didn't really care for was the predictability. It is a YA book, and they have their own kind of predictability. But there were some things I didn't see coming. It is presented well, so if you were to pay close attention you probably could get it. Still I found it very enjoyable.

The next book is Traitor to the Throne.